Top 8 Lakes around Shelter Island Heights
Best lakes around Shelter Island Heights are primarily freshwater ponds located on Shelter Island, a hamlet known for its natural beauty. The island features several accessible freshwater bodies that contribute to its unique ecosystem. These natural features provide opportunities for recreation and immersion in the island's landscape. Shelter Island Heights is characterized by its diverse natural areas, including woodlands, tidal creeks, and protected wildlife refuges.
Best lakes around Shelter Island Heights
- The most popular lakes is Mashomack Preserve, a…
Last updated: July 11, 2026
Mashomack Preserve
Highlight • Forest
Tip by
Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge
Highlight • Natural
While open for visitors, the refuge …
Tip by
Sign up now to discover places like this
Get recommendations on the best single tracks, peaks, & plenty of other exciting outdoor places.
Sign up for free
Rocky Beach on Northwest Harbor
Highlight • Beach
Tip by
Inlet Pond County Park
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Nicoll's Creen
Highlight • Lake
Tip by
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Tips from the Community
Nicoll's Creen is a marshy bay, part of Mashomack Preserve. This area is great for birdwatching and a scenic spot for a break.
0
0
The 187-acre Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge on Long Island's north shore protects the Jessup's Neck peninsula, separating Little Peconic and Noyack Bays. While open for visitors, the refuge emphasizes protecting endangered species like piping plovers by prohibiting feeding wildlife, which can attract predators. Bird watching is excellent, especially for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. To minimize disturbances, no pets are allowed, and part of the beach is closed April-August for nesting birds.
0
0
As you journey through Grace Estate Preserve, you'll discover a nice little rocky beach on the shore of the northwest harbor, this is an excellent isolated spot to relax in nature.
0
0
Be enchanted by the vibrant flutter of butterflies in the dedicated butterfly garden. This colorful haven is a delight for families and nature enthusiasts alike.
0
0
Nestled on Shelter Island, Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre natural wonderland. It features diverse ecosystems from woodlands to tidal creeks, offering picturesque trails for hikers. Rich in biodiversity, it's a haven for birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts, showcasing the beauty of Long Island's wildlife.
1
0
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the primary freshwater bodies on Shelter Island?
The most prominent freshwater body on Shelter Island is Fresh Pond, which is the largest at 15 acres and serves as the island's sole source of drinking water. Other notable freshwater ponds include Ice Pond Park and the scenic pond at Dickerson Park.
Can I swim or engage in water sports at the lakes on Shelter Island?
Yes, Fresh Pond offers opportunities for swimming, kayaking, and paddle-boarding. It's a popular spot for water activities and public access is available.
Are there any family-friendly lake areas around Shelter Island Heights?
Absolutely. Fresh Pond is great for families with swimming and paddle-boarding. Additionally, Mashomack Preserve, Rocky Beach on Northwest Harbor, Inlet Pond County Park, and Nicoll's Creen are all considered family-friendly and offer various natural experiences.
Where can I go birdwatching near the lakes?
Shelter Island offers excellent birdwatching opportunities. Fresh Pond is known for egrets at sunset. Mashomack Preserve is a haven for birdwatchers, and Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge is particularly good for waterfowl in winter and songbirds in spring. Ice Pond Park and Nicoll's Creen, a marshy bay, are also great spots.
Are there hiking trails near the lakes on Shelter Island?
Yes, there are several hiking opportunities. Mashomack Preserve features picturesque trails. Ice Pond Park has a short loop trail, and Dickerson Park also offers a loop trail around its spring-fed pond. You can find more hiking options in the area by visiting the Hiking around Shelter Island Heights guide.
What kind of wildlife can I expect to see around the lakes?
Beyond birds like egrets, waterfowl, and songbirds, the diverse ecosystems around Shelter Island's ponds and preserves support various wildlife. Mashomack Preserve is rich in biodiversity. Fresh Pond is home to fish species such as Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, and Carp.
Are there any historical sites or unique features near the ponds?
Ice Pond Park has a unique historical aspect, as it was once used for cutting ice blocks before modern refrigeration. You can still see a ruined and abandoned incinerator smoke stack, giving the park an 'old world' quality.
What is the best time of year to visit the lakes on Shelter Island?
The lakes and natural areas are enjoyable year-round. Spring brings songbirds to places like Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge, while August is ideal for seeing Swamp Mallows at Dickerson Park. Winter offers excellent waterfowl viewing at the refuge.
Can I bring my dog to the lake areas?
Some areas are dog-friendly, such as Inlet Pond County Park. However, please note that pets are generally not allowed at Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge to protect endangered species.
Are there cycling routes near the lakes on Shelter Island?
Yes, Shelter Island offers various cycling routes. You can explore options like the 'Shelter Island Heights – Dickerson Creek loop' or the 'Shelter Island Heights loop'. Find more details on these and other routes in the Cycling around Shelter Island Heights guide.
What makes Inlet Pond County Park special?
Inlet Pond County Park is known for its dedicated butterfly garden, which is a colorful haven for families and nature enthusiasts. It's also a dog-friendly spot with a lake, beach, and forest areas.
Where can I find a quiet spot to relax in nature near the lakes?
Rocky Beach on Northwest Harbor, accessible through Grace Estate Preserve, is described as an excellent isolated spot to relax in nature. Nicoll's Creen, a marshy bay within Mashomack Preserve, also offers a scenic and peaceful break.
Most popular attractions around Shelter Island Heights
Get inspired with the komoot mobile app
Explore more
Still not found your perfect lake around Shelter Island Heights? Check out the guides of these regions to see even more beautiful places.
