4.5
(5)
164
runners
43
runs
Jogging around Shelter Island Heights offers routes through a landscape characterized by extensive conservation areas, including the Mashomack Preserve, which covers nearly one-third of the island. The terrain features a mix of dense woodlands, wetlands, and marshlands, alongside picturesque beaches and quiet rural roads. Its ferry-only access contributes to a tranquil environment, ideal for outdoor activities. The island's commitment to preserving natural beauty ensures diverse settings for running.
Last updated: August 9, 2026
5
runners
13.1km
01:36
60m
60m
Moderate run. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
7.78km
00:52
30m
30m
Moderate run. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.

Sign up for free
14
runners
9.96km
01:02
60m
60m
Moderate run. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
14
runners
12.5km
01:19
80m
80m
Moderate run. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
11
runners
5.73km
00:36
20m
20m
Moderate run. Good fitness required. Mostly paved surfaces. Suitable for all skill levels.
Get access to more routes and recommendations from other explorers.
Sign up for free
Already have an account?
Our route recommendations are based on thousands of hikes, rides, and runs completed by other people on komoot.
Start today with a free account
Your next adventure awaits.
Login or Signup
Popular around Shelter Island Heights
Nicoll's Creen is a marshy bay, part of Mashomack Preserve. This area is great for birdwatching and a scenic spot for a break.
0
0
Nestled on Shelter Island, Mashomack Preserve is a 2,039-acre natural wonderland. It features diverse ecosystems from woodlands to tidal creeks, offering picturesque trails for hikers. Rich in biodiversity, it's a haven for birdwatchers and nature enthusiasts, showcasing the beauty of Long Island's wildlife.
0
0
Cedar Point County Park, a 607-acre park, offers amazing views of Gardiners Bay and features the decommissioned Cedar Island Lighthouse. Owned by Suffolk County, the park has individual and organized group camping areas. It is dog-friendly, with pets required to be leashed.
0
0
Follow the coast on the picturesque Northwest Path that meanders around Cedar Point County Park. Enjoy seaside bluffs and woods, but be aware of bugs in the summer and ticks.
0
0
Cedar Island Lighthouse, located off the coast of Long Island, has stood since 1839. This historic maritime icon served as a guide for sailors navigating the waters of Long Island Sound, offering safety and guidance through the years.
0
0
There are over 35 dedicated running routes around Shelter Island Heights listed on komoot, offering a variety of options for different preferences and fitness levels.
The terrain in Shelter Island Heights is quite varied, featuring a mix of dense woodlands, wetlands, and marshlands, especially within conservation areas like the Mashomack Preserve. You'll also find picturesque beaches and quiet rural roads, providing diverse surfaces for your run.
Yes, Shelter Island Heights offers several easy running paths. While many routes are moderate, there are at least 3 routes specifically rated as easy, perfect for beginners or those looking for a less strenuous experience. These routes often wind through tranquil areas, allowing you to enjoy the scenery at a comfortable pace.
Absolutely. Many of the running routes in Shelter Island Heights are designed as loops, allowing you to start and finish at the same point. For example, the Joan C. Coles, Red, Yellow, Blue and Green Trail loop is a popular moderate option covering about 13.1 km through varied natural landscapes.
Shelter Island Heights is rich in natural beauty. You can enjoy stunning water views along beaches like Crescent Beach, Wades Beach, and Shell Beach. The Cedar Point Lighthouse Loop Trail offers coastal scenery and views towards the lighthouse. The Mashomack Preserve provides extensive trails through diverse ecosystems, including wetlands and marshlands, where you can spot native birds and lush scenery.
Yes, the island's tranquil atmosphere and numerous easy to moderate paths make it suitable for family jogs. Consider routes that are shorter and have less elevation gain. The quiet rural roads and accessible beach areas can also be great for a family outing, allowing everyone to enjoy the outdoors.
The running routes in Shelter Island Heights are highly rated by the komoot community, with an average score of 5.0 stars. Runners often praise the tranquil environment, diverse natural landscapes, and the peaceful experience offered by the island's conservation areas and quiet roads.
Yes, you can combine your run with exploring local attractions. The Mashomack Preserve itself is a major highlight, offering over 2,000 acres of preserved land. You might also pass by areas like Shelter Island Heights with its charming architecture, or the historic Sylvester Manor Educational Farm, which offers beautiful grounds to explore.
Many routes in Shelter Island Heights provide beautiful water views. Jogging along the island's picturesque beaches such as Crescent Beach, Wades Beach, and Shell Beach offers stunning vistas of the Shelter Island Sound, Southold Bay, and Coecles Harbor. The Cedar Point Lighthouse Loop Trail is another excellent choice for coastal scenery.
Most running routes in Shelter Island Heights are rated as moderate, offering a good balance of challenge and accessibility. There are also a few easy routes for a more relaxed experience and some difficult options for experienced runners seeking a greater challenge. The varied terrain ensures there's something for every ability.
Yes, for those looking for longer runs, Shelter Island Heights has options. The Joan C. Coles, Red, Yellow, Blue and Green Trail loop is a substantial 13.1 km (8.2 miles) route. Another good option is the Running loop from Town of Shelter Island, which covers approximately 12.5 km (7.8 miles).
Shelter Island Heights offers a unique running experience due to its ferry-only access, which contributes to a tranquil and peaceful environment. Nearly one-third of the island is dedicated to conservation, providing extensive natural settings like the Mashomack Preserve. This commitment to preserving natural beauty ensures diverse and serene backdrops for your runs, from dense woodlands to picturesque beaches.


Browse the best Running Trails & Routes in other regions.